EN, página actualES
Subscribe, it's free

HealthcareMedicare

Molina sues CMS, says 2027 star ratings cost it $140 million

A complaint filed Nov 13 in federal court in Washington asks a judge to rescore 16 Molina Medicare Advantage contracts without 14 measures. At least 14 insurers have now sued CMS over their 2027 star ratings.

Grant Whitaker · 3 min read
The E. Barrett Prettyman Federal Courthouse in Washington, D.C., a pale stone building, with the George Meade Memorial statue on its plaza in front
Photo: Jorfer / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

Molina Healthcare says the government’s 2027 Medicare Advantage star ratings will cost it about $140 million in 2028 bonus payments and rebate money. That figure is in a complaint Molina and its state plan companies filed Nov 13 in federal court in Washington, D.C.

The defendants are the Department of Health and Human Services and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). No court has ruled on it.

Chart: At least 14 insurers have sued CMS over 2027 star ratings. Four panels: each insurer's claimed 2028 loss, from CVS Health at over $2 billion to Verda at about $20 million, with Molina's $140 million seventh of 14 and a total of about $4.2 billion; Molina's eight rated contracts, published 2027 rating versus Molina's claimed rating, with Kentucky H1799 and Michigan H5926 rising from 3.5 to 4 stars; cumulative suits from Oct 8 to Nov 16; and suits by court, 10 of 14 in Washington, D.C. Source: the 14 complaints, filed Oct 9 to Nov 13, 2026.
2027 star ratings suits and Molina's Exhibit A. Source: each insurer's complaint (Document 1), filed Oct 9 to Nov 13, 2026; Molina, D.D.C. No. 1:26-cv-04023, via CourtListener RECAP; the others via the Georgetown O'Neill Health Care Litigation Tracker, read Nov 16, 2026. Dollar figures are each insurer's own estimate. The total and the ranking are Health and Tech Now math.

What Molina is asking for

CMS published the 2027 ratings on Oct 8. Molina says 16 of its contracts scored lower than they should have because CMS counted 14 measures it never adopted through public notice and comment. Molina says 10 of the 14 also use data the Medicare law does not let CMS use for star ratings. Examples are Part D prescription claims and complaint tracking records.

The complaint asks the judge to:

  • set aside the 2027 ratings on the 16 contracts and order CMS to recalculate them without the 14 measures
  • order CMS to set 2028 bonuses and rebates on the corrected scores
  • let Molina submit or revise its 2028 bids on the corrected scores

Two contracts would cross 4 stars

Plans rated 4 stars or higher get a quality bonus from CMS. By the complaint’s own table, every contract in the suit would gain at least half a star. Two would cross the 4-star line:

  • H1799, Molina Healthcare of Kentucky, 3.5 stars today, 4 by Molina’s math
  • H5926, Molina Healthcare of Michigan, 3.5 stars today, 4 by Molina’s math

Six contracts are too new to have their own rating. They take Molina’s company wide average, which the complaint says would rise to 3.5 stars. The lowest overall rating in the suit is 2.5 stars, on H8176 in South Carolina. Molina says it would be 3.

The Clover ruling

A federal court in Georgia ruled for Clover Health on May 27, 2026, and ordered CMS to redo Clover’s 2026 ratings after finding 20 measures unlawful. Molina’s complaint says CMS then left those measures out of Clover’s 2027 rating but kept them for everyone else.

Centene and CVS Health make the same argument in their suits. Becker’s Payer Issues counted 11 insurers suing over 2027 stars as of Nov 11, per MedicalDaily. Health and Tech Now has opened 14 complaints over 2027 star ratings, including Molina’s. They were filed from Oct 9 to Nov 13. Elevance Health, which sued Nov 6 in the same Washington court, puts its own loss at about $516 million, per its complaint.

What it means if you are shopping for a plan

Open enrollment runs Oct 15 to Dec 7, per Medicare.gov. The ratings on Plan Finder today are the ones CMS published on Oct 8. A lawsuit does not change them unless a court orders it.

Why it matters: Molina and at least 13 other insurers want the Clover ruling applied to their own 2027 ratings. Their 14 complaints claim about $4.2 billion in 2028 losses combined, by Health and Tech Now math on each insurer’s own estimate. If courts order new scores, CMS would pay 2028 bonuses and rebates on the higher ratings.

$140 million
The NumberMore in 2028 bonus payments and rebate money Molina says it would get if CMS rescored its 2027 star ratingsWithout 14 measures Molina calls unlawful, across 16 contracts (Molina complaint, D.D.C. No. 1:26-cv-04023, filed Nov 13, 2026). Source: Molina Healthcare, Inc. v. HHS, complaint, D.D.C. No. 1:26-cv-04023, filed Nov 13, 2026 (CourtListener RECAP copy)
Sources
  1. Molina Healthcare, Inc. v. HHS, complaint, D.D.C. No. 1:26-cv-04023, filed Nov 13, 2026 (CourtListener RECAP copy) (storage.courtlistener.com)
  2. CourtListener docket, Molina Healthcare, Inc. v. HHS, 1:26-cv-04023 (D.D.C.), read Nov 16, 2026 (courtlistener.com)
  3. Elevance Health v. HHS, complaint, D.D.C. No. 26-3943, filed Nov 6, 2026 (Georgetown tracker copy) (litigationtracker.law.georgetown.edu)
  4. Georgetown O'Neill Health Care Litigation Tracker, the other 13 complaints over 2027 star ratings (Document 1, filed Oct 9 to Nov 13, 2026), read Nov 16, 2026 (litigationtracker.law.georgetown.edu)
  5. MedicalDaily, citing Becker's Payer Issues tally of 11 suits as of Nov 11, published Nov 15, 2026 (medicaldaily.com)
  6. Medicare.gov, Joining a plan (medicare.gov)
More HealthcareMore Medicare
Health and Tech Now is an independent publication. Views are not those of any employer. Public sources only.