Medicare Advantage in Butler County, PA, for 2027.
CMS lists 86 Medicare Advantage plans here for 2027, 5 fewer than 2026 (91). 35,495 people in the county had an individual Medicare Advantage plan in October 2026.
Sources: CMS CY2027 plan file (October 2026 release), CMS CY2026 plan file (September 2026 release), CMS enrollment by county (CPSC), October 2026, CMS 2027 Plan Crosswalk (October 1, 2026), CMS 2027 Star Ratings Data Tables (October 8, 2026). Member counts are floors because CMS hides counts of 10 or fewer.
The county in numbers
Plans that end here for 2027
9 plans with members in the county end or leave it, plus 33 with 10 or fewer members here. CMS moves 1,013 members to another plan, and 22,242 stay in the same plan.
| Plan | Insurer | Members | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| UPMC for Life HMO Rx Choice (HMO) | UPMC Health System | 1,901 | Plan leaves this county |
| UPMC for Life PPO Rx Choice (PPO) | UPMC Health System | 1,419 | Plan leaves this county |
| UPMC for Life HMO Premier Rx (HMO) | UPMC Health System | 1,270 | Plan leaves this county |
| UPMC for Life HMO Deductible Rx (HMO) | UPMC Health System | 880 | Plan leaves this county |
| UPMC for Life PPO Premier Rx (PPO) | UPMC Health System | 229 | Plan leaves this county |
| AARP Medicare Advantage from UHC PA-0011 (PPO) | UnitedHealth | 132 | Plan leaves this county |
| UPMC for Life PPO High Deductible Rx (PPO) | UPMC Health System | 119 | Plan leaves this county |
| UPMC for Life PPO Rx Enhanced (PPO) | UPMC Health System | 91 | Plan leaves this county |
| Aetna Medicare Enhanced (PPO) | CVS Health | 15 | Plan terminated |
Where CMS moves members
| 2026 plan | 2027 plan | Members |
|---|---|---|
| UPMC for Life Complete Care (HMO D-SNP) | UPMC for Life Complete Care (HMO D-SNP) | 1,013 |
| Wellcare Assist (HMO-POS) | Wellcare Simple (HMO-POS) | 10 or fewer |
| Complete Blue PPO Signature (PPO) | Complete Blue PPO Signature (PPO) | 10 or fewer |
Who holds the members
- Highmark Health11,626
- CVS Health9,542
- UPMC Health System8,957
- UnitedHealth2,926
- Humana985
- Elevance Health937
Individual Medicare Advantage members by parent company, October 2026.
Top rated plans sold here
- UHC Nursing Home Plan EX-F002 (PPO I-SNP)UnitedHealth5.0
- Aetna Medicare Advantra Signature Giveback (PPO)CVS Health4.5
- Aetna Medicare Premier Plus (PPO)CVS Health4.5
- Community Blue Medicare HMO Signature (HMO)Highmark Health4.5
- Complete Blue HMO Distinct (HMO)Highmark Health4.5
- Complete Blue PPO Distinct (PPO)Highmark Health4.5
- Complete Blue PPO Merit (PPO)Highmark Health4.5
- Complete Blue PPO Signature (PPO)Highmark Health4.5
2027 overall Star Rating, 4.5 or more. Each plan's measure stars are in the county lookup.
See every plan, premium and copay in the free lookup.
Sort all 86 plans, open each plan's benefits and star measures, and see what each insurer paid agents in 2026.
Open Butler in the lookupWorking this county for AEP?
The AEP 2027 County Kit puts this county and your others in one file: the plans that end, where members land, what is still sold and a crosswalk sheet, with every number tied to its CMS file.
See the AEP 2027 County KitAll Pennsylvania county pages. Facts from public CMS files, prepared by Health and Tech Now. Not plan advice. Check a plan's Summary of Benefits before you enroll.